Cal lives in Denver and must improve his Tiguan to a three-row SUV to accomodate an increasing household. With a price range of as much as $45,000 there are many choices to select from, however he’s discovering the choices overwhelming. He wants our assist to slender the sector and inform him what automobile to purchase.
(Welcome again to What Car Should You Buy? Where we give actual individuals actual recommendation about shopping for automobiles. Do you need us that will help you discover a automobile? Submit your story on our kind.)
Here is the state of affairs.
Quick Facts:
My spouse and I’ve one son (Age- 2) and expect twin boys this fall. We are buying and selling in our Tiguan and wish a three-row SUV. My spouse just like the VW Atlas however I need assistance with what our different choices are. I really feel like there are such a lot of, I simply get misplaced. I hope to spend $45k or much less. I at present drive a Q5 however I’m not actually a automobile man and haven’t any model allegiance. I like them as a result of they’re snug and whereas the Q5 isn’t overly highly effective it has sufficient to merge and move on highways. I simply need one thing that’s nice sufficient to drive. And I’ve already mentioned the minivan thought, that’s a no go.
Budget: as much as $45,000
Location: Denver, CO
Daily Driver: Yes
Wants: 3 rows, respectable energy, consolation
Doesn’t need: A minivan
Expert 1: Tom McParland – No Need To Over Complicate It
Cal, I perceive that this ought to be an easy process with so many high quality choices in that $40,000 ranget, nevertheless it’s simple to get misplaced in the entire selections. You talked about you just like the passing energy of your Q5, and whereas that isn’t a “fast” automobile the turbo motor provides a pleasant enhance whenever you want it. However, I feel you could discover the Atlas to be a bit sluggish because it’s utilizing basically the identical engine however carrying round much more weight. Other rivals on this class supply V6 energy and even hybrid powertrains although the latter will likely be exhausting to supply at an inexpensive worth. You additionally appear to be leaning in direction of a luxury-ish sort of automobile.
Since you have already got good expertise with the German stuff, maybe simply upgrading to the Q7 is the way in which to go. You will sacrifice among the roominess of the Atlas for the efficiency and luxurious upgrades within the Audi, however the three rows ought to be sufficient room for the three kiddos supplied the older brother is happy with being within the again.
While flippantly used stock beneath $45,000 is respectable, you’ll want to concentrate on the three.0T fashions with the twin-turbo V6 that may dash to 60 MPH in about 5 seconds. This will slender your choices a bit, however you’ll be able to rating one thing like this loaded Prestige mannequin in the event you don’t thoughts having some miles on it.
Expert 2: Collin Woodard – Don’t Want A Minivan? Fine.
Tom was good to you, Cal, however I’m not the saint that Tom is. Your spouse might not need a minivan, however she wants a minivan. Oh, she doesn’t wish to appear like a lame mother or father hauling three youngsters round? I’m sorry, however nothing that has room to comfortably haul three youngsters and all their stuff is cool.
The Suburban? Lame. Durango? Lame. Highlander? Lame. Telluride? Lame. Q7? It could also be luxurious, however wouldn’t you already know it, additionally lame. Maybe, simply perhaps, you possibly can make the argument that the Rivian R1S is cool in its personal method. I’d be keen to entertain that argument apart from the truth that you’ll be able to’t get an R1S in your price range, so it’s in the end irrelevant on this explicit dialog.
You and your spouse can discover methods to nonetheless really feel alive whenever you’re not behind the wheel of your loved ones hauler. Have you two thought-about becoming a member of a mountaineering fitness center? I assume Denver’s filled with these and that all of them have good, massive parking heaps so that you can park your new Honda Odyssey. Go inside. Defy gravity. Contemplate mortality as you fall 20 ft onto the pads. Feel the push of endorphins. It’ll be good for you. Then drive residence in your boring, sensible Honda Odyssey.
Still, you insist minivans are off the desk. Fine. Minivans are off the desk. You’re getting the anti-minivan then — a Lexus LX 570. Are those that suit your price range going to have much more miles than you have been most likely hoping for? Of course. Is the LX 570’s third row far wherever close to as sensible because the Odyssey’s third row? Not in any respect. Will you get abysmal gasoline mileage round city? You wager your ass you’ll.
Here’s a 2016 mannequin with 100,000 miles that’s mainly in price range, or in the event you’re keen to just accept even higher-mileage examples, there are all kinds of less-expensive ones within the space similar to this one for $21,000. Either method, a minimum of it’s not a minivan, proper?
Expert 3: José Rodríguez Jr. – Three Diamonds, Three Rows
Cal, a minivan actually could be excellent on this state of affairs. If the minivan is a non-starter, nonetheless, then I’m going to counsel one other automobile that most individuals would assume is a non-starter for causes which can be past me. What you want is a 2024 Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV, which begins at simply over $40,000 when new.
With your price range, you’ll be able to go for a mid-grade mannequin just like the Outlander PHEV SE. Or, as a result of individuals typically overlook the Mitsubishi, you could even discover a high trim SEL for round your price range. Mitsubishi has a status as a forgotten marque within the U.S., which you’ll be able to benefit from that to attain a well-appointed, three-row SUV that comes with a partially-electrified drivetrain. The Outlander has been largely shunned by most people because of its diamond badge, nevertheless it’s no worse than a whole lot of different crossovers.
You’ll save on gas round city with the plug-in hybrid’s 38 miles of EV vary and nonetheless have the power to take your loved ones on journeys with the gas-sipping 2.4-liter inline 4. The Outlander PHEV has Mitsubish’s new AWD system, and whereas the engine might not look like sufficient to maneuver the sizable SUV, we discovered it to be serviceable even with out the enhance from the 2 electrical motors within the PHEV. No, the Outlander isn’t German neither is it quick. But it’s a tremendous car that’s well-suited to its process. Don’t sleep on the Mitsu, is all I’m saying.
Expert 4: Andy Kalmowitz – Stop Lying To Yourself
Cal, it’s time you develop up and admit what you really want in your life: a minivan. I do know, I do know. That’s not what you wish to hear, however I’m going to provide you a actuality verify: not a single three-row SUV available on the market goes to do what you really want it to do. They’re compromised by their very nature. You know what isn’t compromised on the subject of hauling individuals round? A goddamn minivan, Cal. A goddamn minivan.
I’m man, so I’m keen to forgive you for pondering you want a three-row SUV as an alternative of a van. Because of that, I’ve obtained the proper one for you. Buddy, what you want is a Chrysler Pacifica Plug-In Hybrid. There’s no higher car on earth to do what you’re making an attempt to do, plus it checks your whole containers. It’s additionally the most van minivan you should buy proper now.
With a 3.6-liter Pentastar V6 and a 16 kWh battery, the Pacifica PHEV has sufficient oomph that you just received’t be lacking the sportiness of your outdated Audi. On high of that, you get 33 miles of all-electric vary, which can get you some granola cred along with your Denver mates! I’m looking for you, Cal.
Again, as a result of I’m such man, I’ve even discovered the proper Pacifica Hybrid for you: this one, positioned in Denver is a facelifted 2022 mannequin with simply 10,000 miles on the clock that is available in at beneath $40,000 It’s just about model new! You’re not gonna beat that, buddy. I do know you don’t need a minivan, however my good friend, you want a minivan.
Expert 5: Erin Marquis – When Is A Minivan, Not A Minivan?
I, for one, don’t assume your spouse is fallacious for not wanting a minivan—I feel she’s fallacious for pondering minivans aren’t cool. Let’s get to brass tacks right here: minivans are literally probably the most helpful autos on the market and I’m uninterested in pretending they aren’t.
However, I perceive your partner’s road cred is at stake right here. People have to know she’s a mother to not be fucked with. Enter the Kia Carnival, refreshed for 2025 with a model new, extra aggressive entrance finish and a hybrid engine. This is a minivan, make no mistake about it, nevertheless it has massive SUV vibes. It has a naturally aspirated 3.5-liter V6 good for 287 horsepower for the brand new gen (and 290 for the 2024 fashions.) A model new one from the final gen is properly inside your worth vary, even at greater trims that include all the security devices and warnings a younger household wants.
For somewhat additional pep, the 2025 hybrid model provides you much less energy however extra pep with a 72-HP electrical motor offering 242-HP and 271 lb-ft of torque. Plus, you’ll seemingly save somewhat money on gas as soon as the numbers are introduced, and will likely be making your child’s local weather future brighter. And sometime, one in every of them will likely be handed down this van in an effort to begin some kind of band, and also you’ll be glad you could have it.
Source: jalopnik.com